# summary

- Link: https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/
- Published: 2026-05-11T17:21:31+02:00
- Author: dearSA

_Advert_

_Advert – scroll down_

[ have your say](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/#havasay)

There is a national consensus that abuse, exploitation, and criminal conduct within
religious spaces must be addressed decisively. The CRL Rights Commission, through
its Section 22 Ad Hoc Committee, has released a Draft Self-Regulatory Framework 
aimed at fostering transparency, ethical leadership, and protecting the vulnerable.
This framework is presented as a “proactive, voluntary initiative” by the faith 
sector to restore public trust.

While the goal of accountability is shared, there is significant debate over the
mechanism proposed to achieve it:

[The Proposed Framework](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1738150189952-44103674-e29d31d9-c3be5520-2543e5af-62ba)

Includes the establishment of a Christian Practice Council for Ethics and Accountability(
CPCEA), a public register of certified organiations, and a “Seal of Good Standing”.
Critics, including Freedom of Religion SA (FoRSA), point out that while described
as “self-regulation,” the framework explicitly calls for a legislative Act of Parliament
to empower the Council.

[The Analysis](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1738150189975-5d0623dc-47dc31d9-c3be5520-2543e5af-62ba)

Opponents argue the proposal is **Unconstitutional** (violating freedom of religion
and association), **Unnecessary** (existing criminal and civil laws already cover
the harms identified), **Unworkable** (standardizing diverse beliefs is impossible),
and **Unaffordable**.

[Alternative Solutions](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1738150854013-bb98f5fb-7d0931d9-c3be5520-2543e5af-62ba)

Critics advocate for a model of “Accountability without Control”. This focuses on
the consistent **enforcement of existing laws** (such as the Children’s Act and 
criminal law) and the adoption of voluntary, sector-led initiatives like the **Religious
Freedom Charter** and umbrella bodies like **SACOFF**.

[The "Wildcard" Perspective: Why This Matters to Everyone](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1738151172108-10076802-4d0031d9-c3be5520-2543e5af-62ba)

This campaign is not limited to those of faith. It serves as a critical test of **
South Africa’s constitutional democracy**. If the State establishes a statutory 
council to “license” a fundamental right like religion, it sets a legal precedent
for similar “councils” to oversee other sectors—including the press, community activists,
and private associations.

### _Questions and answers_

[What exactly is this "Draft Self-Regulatory Framework"?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1763554389233-fdb8fee6-6da45520-2543e5af-62ba)

It is a document prepared by the Section 22 Ad Hoc Committee for the CRL Rights 
Commission. Its stated goal is to create a legislative framework to setup a peer-
review system of accountability, registration and ethical leadership within all 
religious organisations.

[The document is titled "for the Christian Sector." Does this affect other religions?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1763554389265-aa09206a-77665520-2543e5af-62ba)

While the current draft is specifically focused on the Christian sector , the CRL
Chair has stated that the ultimate goal is an **Act of Parliament** to create a 
Council for the entire religious sector. If we allow a fundamental right to become
conditional on a State-enabled “seal” or license, the same logic can eventually 
be applied to the press, NGOs, and community activists.

[What is the "Seal of Good Standing"?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1763554389298-fbc55a3c-817c5520-2543e5af-62ba)

Under the proposed framework, religious institutions that comply with specific governance
and ethical standards will be awarded a “Seal of Good Standing”.

    - _The Reward:_ It serves as a public signal that the organization is trustworthy.
    - _The Penalty:_ Organizations that do not comply or lose their seal may face
      public notification and deregistration.

[Why are some calling this "State Control" rather than "Self-Regulation"?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1771840733358-e4b2d08e-b226e5af-62ba)

True self-regulation is entirely voluntary and led by the sector itself. Critics
point out that this framework:

    1. Was initiated by a State body (the CRL).
    2. Proposes a legislative framework created by an Act of Parliament.
    3. Would be implemented by a statutory council with legal authority.
        When a fundamental
       right like religion becomes dependent on a government-sanctioned license or “
       seal,” it moves from being a protected right to a **conditional privilege. **

[What are the four main objections?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1771840767171-e194ee95-bf82e5af-62ba)

Opponents of the framework categorize their objections into four main pillars:

  |  **Argument** |  **Definition** |  
   |  **Unconstitutional** |

It violates Sections 15, 18, and 31 of the Constitution by making religious practice conditional on State-enabled approval .

  |  
 |  **Unnecessary** |

South Africa already has criminal, child protection, and financial laws to prosecute abuse. The issue is **enforcement**, not a lack of law.

  |  
 |  **Unworkable** |

Religion is too diverse to be standardised like a profession; a central council cannot determine which “ethics” or “doctrines” are correct.

  |  
 |  **Unaffordable** |

It imposes unnecessary financial burdens on faith communities and taxpayers to run a new regulatory bureaucracy.

  |

[Isn’t the State just trying to stop criminal abuse in churches?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1778514276153-f02b2c38-6da8)

Criminal acts like assault, fraud, and sexual abuse are already illegal under existing
South African law. Critics argue that we do not need new “religious laws” to stop
crimes; we need the police and NPA to consistently **enforce the laws we already
have.**

[I’m not religious. Why should I participate in this campaign?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1778514310953-de18ee62-fbbb)

This is a test case for **all civil liberties.** If the government can successfully
create a statutory council to “oversee” the exercise of one constitutional right(
religion), it sets a legal precedent to do the same for others .

    - _The Logic:_ If “bad actors” in religion justify a State council, then “bad
      actors” in the** media, community activism, or NGOs** could be used to justify
      State oversight of those sectors next.

[Will my comments actually be read by the Committee?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/#1778514431974-3943c7f1-7896)

Yes. By using the DearSouthAfrica platform, your specific comments are delivered
directly to the Section 22 Ad Hoc Committee and the relevant parliamentary structures.
This creates a formal, legal record of public sentiment that must be considered 
during the legislative process .

The draft regulations

 ⌊Loader⌉ Loading...

 ⌊EAD Logo⌉ Taking too long?

 ⌊Reload⌉ Reload document

 | [ ⌊Open⌉ Open in new tab ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/11172509/Final-Draft-Christian-Sector-Self-Regulatory-Framework-in-RSA.pdf)

[Download [136.02 KB] ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/11172509/Final-Draft-Christian-Sector-Self-Regulatory-Framework-in-RSA.pdf)

The CRL notice

 ⌊Loader⌉ Loading...

 ⌊EAD Logo⌉ Taking too long?

 ⌊Reload⌉ Reload document

 | [ ⌊Open⌉ Open in new tab ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/14144909/THE-LAUNCH-OF-THE-NATIONAL-CONSULTATION-FOR-THE-DRAFT-REGULATORY-FRAMEWORK-IN-SOUTH.pdf)

[Download [171.57 KB] ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/14144909/THE-LAUNCH-OF-THE-NATIONAL-CONSULTATION-FOR-THE-DRAFT-REGULATORY-FRAMEWORK-IN-SOUTH.pdf)

### _In the News_

    - Mail&Guardian — [CRL and faith groups at odds](https://mg.co.za/thought-leader/opinion/2026-04-02-crl-and-faith-groups-at-odds/)
    - FoRSA — [Briefing Memo:](https://www.forsa.org.za/articles/briefing-memo---what-changed-on-11-february-2026)
      What Changed in Parliament (Feb 2026): A detailed account of the COGTA Portfolio
      Committee hearing where cross-faith opposition was formally placed on record.
    - Christian Daily — [South African Church Defenders accuse CRL Rights Commission of deception over church regulation plans](https://www.christiandaily.com/news/south-african-church-defenders-accuse-crl-rights-commission-of-deception-over-church-regulation-plans)
    - JoyNews — [Despite assurances, legislated “self-regulation” is state control by another name](https://joynews.co.za/despite-assurances-legislated-self-regulation-is-state-control-by-another-name/)
    - IOL — [Backlash against CRL Commission’s new oversight committee for religious groups](https://iol.co.za/mercury/2025-10-05-backlash-against-crl-commissions-new-oversight-committee-for-religious-groups/)
    - Christian Daily — [New committee seeking to ‘preserve dignity and maintain order’ renews debate on religious regulation in South Africa](https://www.christiandaily.com/news/new-independent-committee-renews-debate-on-religious-regulation-in-south-africa)
    - TimesLive — [State regulation of religion not the way to go: Freedom of Religion SA](https://www.timeslive.co.za/news/south-africa/2025-03-03-state-regulation-of-religion-not-the-way-to-go-freedom-of-religion-sa/)
    - Saturday Star — [Church leaders fight back against government control plans](https://thestar.co.za/saturday-star/news/2025-03-03-church-leaders-fight-back-against-government-control-plans/)
    - Central News — [CRL Rights Commission Launches Section 22 Ad Hoc Committee at Rhema Bible Church to Tackle Religious Sector Abuses and Draft Regulatory Framework](https://centralnews.co.za/crl-rights-commission-launches-section-22-ad-hoc-committee-at-rhema-bible-church-to-tackle-religious-sector-abuses-and-draft-regulatory-framework/)

**FoRSA.** On the 21st of April, FOR SA met with the CRL Rights Commission’s Section
22 Committee in Johannesburg to raise serious constitutional concerns regarding 
the proposed framework for the Christian sector.
 We made it clear that: ⚖️ Abuse
and misconduct must be addressed 📜 But legislation regulating religion fundamentally
changes the relationship between the State and faith communities The process is 
now formally underway and provincial consultations are expected to continue across
South Africa over the coming months.

**SA Church Defenders.** Press Conference Regarding the CRL Rights Commission – 
Section 22 Committee

### _Statements and media releases_

Click on a logo to view.

Want to display your organisation’s statement? [Click here. ](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary/ cannabis@dearsouthafrica.co.za?subject=org info for Cannabis regulations info page)

Close

### Cape Independence Party

 **CAPEXIT Party strongly opposes the Business Licensing Bill in its entirety on
all points:**

**Preferential licensing**
 The Bill explicitly empowers the Minister to grant licences
on a “preferential” basis and to impose conditions that advance “historically disadvantaged
individuals” or other designated groups. This is nothing less than state-sanctioned
racial and ideological discrimination dressed up as transformation policy.

CAPEXIT rejects the notion that the state has any legitimate role in deciding which
racial or social group may or may not operate a business. Such preferential licensing
will:

    - Reintroduce apartheid-era economic controls under a new ideological banner;
    - Create a cronyist system where access to markets is determined by political
      connections and demographic criteria rather than merit, innovation or consumer
      demand;
    - Discourage both domestic and foreign investment, as investors will rightly
      fear that their businesses can be denied licences or subjected to arbitrary
      conditions on racial or political grounds.

No free society licenses businesses on the basis of the owner’s skin colour or historical
narrative. This clause alone renders the entire Bill unconstitutional and morally
indefensible.

**Principles of business licensing**
 The Bill fails to articulate any coherent,
objective, or proportionate principle for requiring a general business licence in
the first place. Instead, it presumes that every enterprise – from a street vendor
to a multinational corporation – must seek prior permission from the state simply
to exist and trade.

This reverses the fundamental principle of a free economy: citizens should be free
to engage in lawful economic activity without state permission unless there is a
clear, evidence-based justification (e.g. public health, safety or environmental
protection).

The Bill provides no such justification. It is a blanket assault on economic freedom,
reminiscent of the licence-permit raj that crippled India’s economy for decades.
Requiring a general “business licence” in addition to existing sector-specific permits(
liquor, health, zoning, etc.) serves no legitimate public purpose – only the purpose
of expanding state control and creating new opportunities for rent-seeking and corruption.

**Powers of inspectors**
 The Bill grants inspectors extraordinarily broad and invasive
powers, including warrantless entry into private premises, seizure of documents 
and goods, and the ability to close businesses on the spot. These powers are ripe
for abuse and will be weaponised against political opponents, non-compliant businesses,
and any entrepreneur who refuses to pay bribes.

In a country already plagued by corruption scandals, handing unelected officials
the power to enter and shut down businesses without judicial oversight is an open
invitation to extortion. Small businesses, spaza shops, and informal traders – many
of them immigrant-owned – will be particularly vulnerable to harassment and shakedowns.
Far from promoting transformation, this will simply create a new class of “licence
inspectors” who enrich themselves at the expense of the poor.

**More red tape**
 South Africa already ranks poorly on the World Bank’s Ease of
Doing Business index, largely because of regulatory overreach. This Bill adds yet
another layer of costly, time-consuming bureaucracy on top of SARS registration,
municipal permits, B-BBEE compliance, UIF, COIDA, sector SETA requirements, and 
dozens of other licences.

The compliance costs – application fees, mandatory consultations, endless paperwork,
and the risk of arbitrary refusal – will crush startups and force thousands of small
businesses to close or remain informal. Jobs will be lost, investment will flee,
and the tax base will shrink. The Western Cape, which has consistently outperformed
the rest of South Africa precisely because of lighter and more efficient regulation,
will see its competitive advantage deliberately sabotaged by Pretoria.

**Conclusion**
 The Business Licensing Bill is not reform – it is economic sabotage.
It centralises power in the hands of an already overreaching and underperforming
national government, reintroduces racial criteria into commerce, and erects new 
barriers to entrepreneurship at a time when South Africa desperately needs growth
and jobs.

CAPEXIT calls for the complete withdrawal of this Bill. The people of the Western
Cape, and indeed all South Africans who believe in freedom, will not accept a return
to a permit-based economy controlled by bureaucrats and political gatekeepers.

For a free, prosperous, and non-racial future, this Bill must be rejected in its
entirety.
