# state control of religion

- Link: https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/
- Published: 2026-05-11T16:41:23+02:00
- Author: dearSA

![](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/15165612/Stat-regulation-
of-religion-h2-scaled.jpg "Stat regulation of religion h2")

![](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/15171020/State-
regulation-of-religion-h3-scaled.jpg "State regulation of religion h3")

![](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/15172213/Stat-regulation-
of-religion-h4-scaled.jpg "Stat regulation of religion h4")

![](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/05/15180235/Stat-regulation-
of-religion-h5-scaled.jpg "Stat regulation of religion h5")

![DEAR-SOUTH-AfFRICA](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2023/
02/08135845/DEAR-SOUTH-AfFRICA.png "DEAR-SOUTH-AfFRICA")

0

comments individually delivered to the Commission, so far

       * No I do not support the draft 28075
       * Yes I do 813
       * Not fully 232

### The CRL Rights Commission is again pushing for Parliament to pass legislation and implement a system of State regulation of religion.

This initiative, led by the CRL’s Section 22 Ad Hoc Committee, is presented as a
voluntary effort by the Church to promote transparency, ethical leadership, and 
the protection of vulnerable congregants from abuse and exploitation.

While the CRL maintains that this is not about State control, organisations like
Freedom of Religion SA (FOR SA) have raised serious alarms and many of the major
Christian faith communities and denominations are opposing the CRL’s initiative.
They argue that the framework serves as a “mask” for a legislative agenda that will
eventually result in an Act of Parliament and a statutory council with the power
to deregister religious leaders and institutions.
 click the link for more info,
or scroll down to have your say

[ view info, statements, documents and videos](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary)

Michael Swain from Freedom Of Religion SA (FOR SA) explains the issue.

## 󠀁[ view comments from other participants before you have a say](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/comments)󠁿

**Do you support the Draft Self-Regulatory Framework for the Christian Sector as
presented by the CRL Rights Commission? **

**What is your concern? (scroll down for an explanation of each) **

As you've chosen "all of the above", if you had to choose one concern, what would
it be?

**Would you like to use FOR SA's objection? **

the fields below are optional ——————————

**What is your preferred channel for feedback on this campaign?**

**Your preferred language?**

**What is your status? (for our reporting purposes only) **

 **Check your email address then hit send! You will be redirected to a confirmation
page. **

![D-icon](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/11192438/
D-icon-40x40-1.png "D-icon-40x40")

### _Top concerns_

[Constitutional Violation & Conditional Rights](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/#1770131112026-5a70eb21-10f15d6a-e1cda030-8f57)

### Constitutional Rights Are Not State Grants

    - _The Conflict: _
       Freedom of religion and association are fundamental constitutional
      rights, not state-licensed privileges. They cannot lawfully be made conditional
      on State approval.
    - _The Overreach: _
       The proposed framework would make these rights conditional
      on a State-enabled structure, through devices such as a “Seal of Good Standing”,
      mandatory registration, licensing, or approved peer-review bodies.
    - _The Section Violations: _
       The proposal violates Section 15 (freedom of religion
      and conscience), Section 18 (freedom of association, including the freedom
      not to be compelled into a State-approved body), and Section 31 (the right
      of religious communities to maintain their own institutions) of the Constitution.
    - _The Limitation Test: _
       Under Section 36, any limitation must be reasonable,
      justifiable, and the least restrictive means available. Existing laws of general
      application already address every harm cited by the CRL, so this proposal 
      fails that test and is an unconstitutional overreach.

[Duplication of Existing Laws](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/#1770131112043-0e75ef86-4b6c5d6a-e1cda030-8f57)

### Existing Law Is Already Sufficient

    - _Sufficient Protection: _
       South Africa already has a comprehensive legal 
      framework capable of addressing every category of harm cited by the CRL, in
      religious spaces and in every other sector.
    - _Applicable Laws: _
       Criminal law (assault, fraud, theft, intimidation, coercion,
      sexual offences), the Children’s Act, domestic violence and vulnerable-person
      protections, NPO and tax law, labour law, consumer protection, and ordinary
      civil remedies already provide strong, overlapping protections.
    - _The Real Issue: _
       The problem is not the absence of law, but weaknesses 
      in enforcement, reporting, coordination, and public awareness of remedies 
      already available.
    - _Inefficiency: _
       A new regulatory system duplicates existing frameworks and
      diverts resources from the effective enforcement of laws already on the books.
      The proper remedy is enforcement, not converting a constitutional freedom 
      into a licensed activity.

[State Interference in Religious Ethics and Belief](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/#1770131281853-5866958a-b51c5d6a-e1cda030-8f57)

### Doctrine Is Not the State’s to Decide

    - _Illegal vs. Unethical: _
       The State has a legitimate duty to prosecute illegal
      conduct. It has no jurisdiction over what is merely “unethical” within a religious
      community. The CRL Chair has publicly stated that the proposed council would
      extend State authority beyond illegality into ethics. That is incompatible
      with the Constitution.
    - _Subjectivity: _
       “Ethics” in a religious context are not neutral. They are
      inextricably bound to specific doctrines, traditions, and conscience. There
      is no neutral State standard for what counts as acceptable belief, ministry,
      or religious discipline.
    - _Intrusion: _
       Once the State claims authority to regulate religious ethics,
      it begins, directly or indirectly, to determine which beliefs and practices
      are “acceptable”. This is a direct intrusion into private conscience and doctrine.
      South African courts already recognise the danger of State entanglement in
      doctrinal disputes, and history shows that State enforcement of orthodoxy 
      leads to exclusion, oppression, and abuse.

[Practical Impossibility of Standardisation](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/#1770131323251-266a4851-6c9c5d6a-e1cda030-8f57)

### Why Standardisation Cannot Work

    - _Diversity of Faith: _
       Religion is diverse, decentralised, and doctrinally
      contested. Leadership is recognised through vocation, calling, doctrine, ordination,
      or community recognition, not through a State-defined professional model. 
      Section 22 of the Constitution protects the right to choose a trade or occupation;
      it does not authorise the licensing of religion. The assumption that religion
      can be regulated like law, medicine, or accounting is fundamentally flawed.
    - _Unresolvable Questions: _
       No central body can answer the questions a regulatory
      regime requires. Which doctrine becomes the standard? Who qualifies as a “
      religious practitioner”: pastors, elders, worship leaders, counsellors, Sunday
      school teachers, ministry volunteers, small-group leaders, and on what criteria?
      How are conflicting beliefs adjudicated? There is no neutral State standard
      available for any of these.
    - _Selective Enforcement: _
       In practice, an unworkable system is enforced selectively.
      The result is bias, inequality, and ongoing conflict, while genuine accountability
      is no better served than under existing law.

[Dangerous Precedent for All Civil Society (The Wildcard)](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/#1777463528421-99209505-be9aa030-8f57)

### Civil Society’s Stake in This Debate

    - _Beyond Religion: _
       This is not only a Christian sector issue. The constitutional
      principles at stake (freedom of association, freedom of conscience, and protection
      from State interference in voluntary communities) apply to every private association
      in South Africa.
    - _The Precedent: _
       If the State creates a statutory council to license a fundamental
      right like freedom of religion, it lays a legal template that can be applied
      to any other association: the press, NGOs, professional bodies, community 
      organisations, advocacy groups, or labour formations. The reasoning that justifies
      it for one sector becomes available for use against any other.
    - _State Control: _
       The deeper shift is constitutional. It moves South Africa
      from a model in which freedoms are protected by default to one in which freedoms
      are “approved” and “regulated” by the State. Every citizen has a stake in 
      resisting that shift.

[Restrictions on Governance and Foreign Nationals](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/#1777463564023-1723eae7-45f6a030-8f57)

### Immigration, Not Religious Regulation

    - _Internal Interference: _
       The framework dictates internal governance, including
      how leaders are appointed, recognised, or removed. Section 31 protects religious
      communities’ right to maintain their own institutions, and Section 18 protects
      the right not to be forced into State-approved governance structures.
    - _Nationality Requirements: _
       The mandate that churches founded by foreign
      nationals have a South African majority on their local governing structure
      addresses concerns that belong at the immigration stage, not in religious 
      regulation. The Department of Home Affairs already has, and can sharpen, the
      tools to scrutinise foreign religious workers at the visa stage. In the United
      States, for example, religious worker visas require evidence of ordination
      and letters of reference from a recognised religious organisation. This places
      the question where it belongs: under ordinary immigration law, not under a
      religious regulatory regime.
    - _Autonomy: _
       Once the State sets the rules for who may lead within a religious
      community, it has crossed from legitimate immigration scrutiny and law enforcement
      into the regulation of religion itself. Religious communities must remain 
      free to determine their own internal leadership in accordance with their own
      doctrines and traditions.

### _Perspectives: What is the debate?_

The proposal to regulate the religious sector has sparked a significant national
debate. Below are the primary arguments from both the Section 22 Ad Hoc Committee
and the opposing civil society groups like Freedom of Religion SA (FOR SA).

[Arguments in Favour of the Framework](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/#1770892117175-dfc38055-c8385d6a-e1cda030-8f57)

    - _Standardising Accountability: _
       Proponents argue the framework is essential
      to establish clear standards for internal governance, financial transparency,
      and ethical leadership within religious organisations to restore public trust.
    - _Protecting the Vulnerable: _
       The initiative aims to safeguard marginalised
      communities, including the poor and those with disabilities, from exploitation
      and harmful “healing” practices.
    - _Sector-Led Reform: _
       The Committee describes the process as a voluntary,
      proactive initiative “by the Church, for the Church,” allowing the sector 
      to govern itself rather than facing direct State intervention.
    - _Independent Oversight: _
       Supporters emphasise that the proposed Christian
      Practice Council for Ethics and Accountability (CPCEA) would be an independent
      body of respected religious leaders and experts, not a government department.
    - _What the Terms of Reference Say: _
       Although the process is framed as voluntary
      and sector-led, the Section 22 Committee’s Terms of Reference expressly mandate
      a “legislative framework”. By definition, this requires an Act of Parliament
      and would establish a statutory body with legal authority. No amount of “voluntary”
      or “self-regulatory” framing can change what the Terms of Reference actually
      require.

[Arguments in Opposition to the Framework](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/#1770892117205-3c7c32e1-ce3d5d6a-e1cda030-8f57)

    - _The Legislative “Mask”: _
       While the consultation is presented as voluntary,
      the proposed end-point is a statutory council created by an Act of Parliament,
      with legal authority that would include the power to deregister institutions
      and to accredit or withdraw recognition from religious leaders. The voluntary
      framing of the process does not change the regulatory character of what is
      being proposed.
    - _The Four Main Objections: _
       Opponents argue that the proposal is unconstitutional(
      violating sections 15, 18, and 31 of the Constitution and failing the section
      36 limitations test), unnecessary (existing laws already address every category
      of harm cited by the CRL), unworkable (religion is diverse and doctrinally
      contested, with no neutral State standard), and unaffordable (reported costs
      run into hundreds of millions).
    - _Regulation of “Ethics”: _
       The CRL Chair has publicly stated that State authority
      should extend beyond illegality into the regulation of “ethics”. This is incompatible
      with the Constitution, because it moves the State from prosecuting criminal
      conduct into determining matters of belief, doctrine, and private conscience.
    - _A Precedent for All Civil Society: _
       A State-enabled council to license 
      one fundamental right lays a legal template that can later be applied to other
      voluntary associations, including the press, NGOs, professional bodies, and
      community organisations. The constitutional shift from freedoms protected 
      by default to freedoms approved by the State has implications well beyond 
      religion.

[ View more info](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/state-control-of-religion/summary)
