# comments

- Link: https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/immigration-paper/comments/
- Published: 2026-02-12T12:40:56+02:00
- Author: dearSA

_Advert_

_Advert – scroll down_

Displaying the **5** latest comments.

[ view more ...](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/immigration-paper/comments2/)

  |

Submitted

 |

first-name

 |

support

 |

top-concern

 |

message

 |  
   |

2026-11-20 14:20:48 +02:00

 |

valentine

 |

No I do not

 |

Mass Surveillance (The Intelligent Population Register)

 |

There's too much corruption in SAPS, police especially Hillbrow police are abusing power exhorting money from illegal immigrants daily, from 1500 daily, my colleague had police come inside their private property with keys from one of the tenants arrested outside for documentation & they demanded identification from everyone in the house only to release them later after after extortion of 1500..

 | 
 |

2026-07-03 14:57:06 +02:00

 |

Abigail

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

 | 
 |

2026-05-27 12:03:29 +02:00

 |

Donavan

 |

Not fully

 |

All of the above

 |

 | 
 |

2026-05-25 18:23:53 +02:00

 |

keith

 |

Yes I do

 |

Citizenship Reform

 |

 | 
 |

2026-05-17 17:41:50 +02:00

 |

Mrs L

 |

No I do not

 |

Citizenship Reform

 |

 |

[What SUPPORTERS say (The "National Security & Growth" Argument)](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/immigration-paper/comments/#1770892117175-dfc38055-c838)

    - _“We need to know who is in our country.”_
       Supporters argue that the current
      system is chaotic and that a mandatory Intelligent Population Register is 
      the only way to secure the state, reduce identity fraud, and stop syndicates
      from selling fake South African IDs.
    - _“Citizenship should be earned, not waited for.”_
       They believe the shift 
      to a Merit-Based System is smart economics. Instead of giving citizenship 
      to anyone who simply waits 5 years, South Africa should prioritize people 
      who bring skills, investment, and jobs—similar to systems in Australia or 
      Canada.
    - _“Stop Asylum Shopping.”_
       Supporters back the “First Safe Country” rule, 
      arguing that South Africa cannot carry the burden for the entire continent.
      If a refugee travels through safe countries (like Tanzania or Zambia) to get
      here, they should have sought protection there first.

[What OPPONENTS say (The "Privacy & Rights" Argument)](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/immigration-paper/comments/#1770892117205-3c7c32e1-ce3d)

    - _“This is mass surveillance disguised as immigration reform.” _
       Opponents
      warn that the Intelligent Population Register allows the police and State 
      Security Agency to access your private biometric data without a warrant. They
      argue this creates a “police state” capability that violates Section 14 (Privacy)
      of the Constitution.
    - _“It punishes the vulnerable.” _
       Critics argue that the “First Safe Country”
      principle is practically impossible to enforce fairly and will result in genuine
      refugees being turned away to face persecution, violating international human
      rights.
    - _“The system is broken, not the law.” _
       Many argue that the Department of
      Home Affairs is already failing to process basic documents due to corruption
      and incompetence. Handing them more power and a massive new digital system
      will likely result in more chaos and looting, rather than efficiency.

[ have your say](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/immigration-paper/#havasay)
