# summary

- Link: https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/
- Published: 2026-08-25T14:53:29+02:00
- Author: dearSA

_Advert_

_Advert – scroll down_

Public participation report – with all public comments

 ⌊Loader⌉ Loading...

 ⌊EAD Logo⌉ Taking too long?

 ⌊Reload⌉ Reload document

 | [ ⌊Open⌉ Open in new tab ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/10174615/Electricity-Transformation-Paper.-compressed.pdf)

[Download [6.22 MB] ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/11/10174615/Electricity-Transformation-Paper.-compressed.pdf)

This report was delivered to The Department of Electricity and Energy on 20 September
2026.

If you see value in what we do, please chip in – even a small amount helps tremendously.

[ click here to chip in](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/thankyou/)

[ have your say](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/#havasay)

The Department of Electricity and Energy’s Electricity Sector Market Transformation
Position Paper (published in Government Gazette No. 55226, Notice 7841 on 21 August
2026) marks South Africa’s formal transition from a state-monopoly electricity model
to an unbundled, competitive wholesale market. With written comments closing on 
20 September 2026 (30 days from publication), structuring an effective public participation
campaign requires translating this complex market architecture into clear, high-
stakes public choices.

[Executive Summary & Policy Blueprint](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/#1738150189952-44103674-e29d31d9-c3be5520-25434efa-277d)

The position paper operationalises the Electricity Regulation Amendment Act (ERAA)
of 2024 by outlining the architecture of the South African Wholesale Electricity
Market (SAWEM):

    - _Market Unbundling:_
       Eskom is being split into legally distinct operating
      entities for Generation, Transmission (NTCSA), and Distribution.
    - _The South African Wholesale Electricity Market (SAWEM):_
       A voluntary centralised
      trading platform administered by a Market Operator (MO) for Day-Ahead and 
      Intra-Day trading, alongside privately negotiated bilateral contracts and 
      a mandatory real-time balancing mechanism.
    - _Transmission & System Operation: _
       The National Transmission Company of 
      South Africa (NTCSA) serves as the independent Transmission Network Service
      Provider (TNSP), System Operator (SO), Market Operator (MO), and Central Purchasing
      Agency (CPA). Private Independent Transmission Projects (ITPs) will be introduced
      to accelerate grid expansion.
    - _Retail vs. “Wires” Separation: _
       Municipal and Eskom distribution businesses
      will be unbundled into separate regulated network (“wires”) businesses and
      licensed retail/trading businesses.
    - _Customer Tiers: _
       Large power users exceeding a determined capacity threshold(
      e.g., 1 MW) become “Eligible Customers” free to choose independent traders
      or buy wholesale, while residential households and small businesses remain“
      Captive Customers” under NERSA-regulated municipal tariffs.
    - _Balance Responsibility & Penalties: _
       All participants (generators, traders,
      eligible buyers) must accurately forecast and schedule energy, facing direct
      financial liability for grid imbalances.
    - _Timelines: _
       Soft-launch of wholesale operations in 2026, followed by phased
      participant opening from 2027.

[Market Concerns, Expert Warnings & Critical Flashpoints](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/#1738150189975-5d0623dc-47dc31d9-c3be5520-25434efa-277d)

Recent industry statements and media reporting highlight key systemic friction points:

    - _The “Captive Ratepayer Trap” & Municipal Defection: _
       Municipalities rely
      heavily on electricity surpluses from large commercial users to cross-subsidise
      indigent households and basic services. Allowing high-paying users to buy 
      power directly from private traders risks leaving municipal distribution entities
      with insolvent revenue models and stranded captive households.
    - _Market Power & Eskom Dominance: _
       Eskom Generation still controls the vast
      majority of baseload power. Industry analysts warn that without strict bidding
      regulation and vesting contracts, Eskom could exercise market power (economic
      or physical withholding) or suffer financial collapse.
    - _NTCSA Multiple-Hat Conflicts of Interest: _
       |Consolidating network ownership,
      market operation, system dispatch, and the Central Purchasing Agency (holding
      legacy IPP contracts) under the NTCSA creates structural conflicts of interest
      that could disadvantage independent power producers and private traders.
    - _The “Anti-Free-Riding” Clause & Grid Defection Charges: _
       The paper explicitly
      targets off-grid and partial-solar users by prioritising fixed capacity network
      charges over volumetric usage tariffs to recover sunk grid costs, potentially
      penalising private embedded generation.
    - _Market Readiness & Balancing Penalties: _
       Eskom leadership and market participants
      have cautioned that premature launches without robust credit risk frameworks,
      financial settlement systems, and municipal debt solutions could trigger market
      concentration or systemic failure.

### _Questions and answers_

[I invested thousands in rooftop home solar to escape load shedding. How does this policy affect me?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/#1763554389233-fdb8fee6-6da45520-25434efa-277d)

The position paper explicitly identifies grid-tied rooftop solar households under
its “anti-free-riding” principle (Section 1.2.2). Because solar users consume fewer
kilowatt-hours from the grid while still relying on it at night or during overcast
weather, the policy argues they are not paying their fair share of fixed infrastructure
costs. To address this, the framework mandates a shift away from pure per-unit consumption
billing toward higher mandatory fixed monthly capacity and network charges for all
grid-connected users, regardless of how much electricity they actually draw.

[Will unbundling and a competitive wholesale market make household electricity tariffs cheaper or more expensive?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/#1763554389265-aa09206a-77665520-25434efa-277d)

In the long term, competitive generation should lower wholesale production costs.
However, in the medium term, ordinary residential households face two pricing pressures:

    - _Unbundled Network Charges:_ Fixed maintenance costs for transmission lines
      and local substations will be billed separately from the energy itself.
    - _The Loss of Commercial Subsidies:_
       If large corporate customers leave municipal
      retail supply to buy cheaper power directly from independent traders, municipalities
      lose their highest-margin revenue stream. Unless local distribution structures
      are overhauled, councils may hike tariffs on captive residential users to 
      balance their budgets.

[What mechanisms exist to stop Eskom or private power consortiums from manipulating wholesale market prices?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/#1763554389298-fbc55a3c-817c5520-25434efa-277d)

In an open wholesale market, dominant players can theoretically drive up prices 
through economic withholding (bidding electricity into the day-ahead market at artificially
inflated prices) or physical withholding (deliberately holding back generation capacity
to create artificial shortages). Because Eskom Generation will continue to control
the bulk of South Africa’s baseload capacity for years, the paper proposes:

    - A dedicated Market Surveillance Unit (MSU) to monitor trading for collusive
      behaviour.
    - _Vesting Contracts:_ Multi-year transitional contracts that lock in fixed 
      baseline prices between Eskom and distributors to limit market volatility 
      during early years.
    - _NERSA Bid Regulation:_ Direct regulatory power allowing NERSA and the Competition
      Commission to cap or audit Eskom Generation’s bids into the market platform.

[Can ordinary households choose who they buy electricity from under this new model?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/#1771840733358-e4b2d08e-b2264efa-277d)

**No**. The position paper maintains a strict distinction between “Eligible Customers”
and “Captive Customers”. Only large industrial and commercial consumers exceeding
a determined threshold (e.g., 1 MW demand) will initially be permitted to shop around
and contract with private electricity traders or buy from the centralised market.
All residential households and smaller commercial entities remain captive customers
of their local municipal or Eskom distribution retailer under regulated tariffs.

[Can residential solar owners sell their excess power back into the South African Wholesale Electricity Market (SAWEM)?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/#1771840767171-e194ee95-bf824efa-277d)

Not directly into the wholesale day-ahead trading platform. The wholesale market
will enforce minimum capacity thresholds (such as 1 MW) and strict prudential and
technical balancing requirements. Residential solar exports will continue to rely
on local municipal Small-Scale Embedded Generation (SSEG) feed-in tariff programmes,
which will feed into the local distributor’s portfolio rather than direct wholesale
market settlement

[What is "Balance Responsibility," and could it lead to hidden costs for end-users?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/#1787661060978-756c01ae-8671)

Under SAWEM, every generator, trader, and municipal buyer is legally and financially
responsible for matching the power they scheduled to deliver or consume against 
what is actually produced and used in real time. If a municipal distributor or private
trader under-forecasts demand or experiences unplanned deviations, they face steep
imbalance penalties settled through the Market Operator’s balancing mechanism. If
municipal distributors manage their scheduling poorly, these financial balancing
penalties could be passed down into consumer tariffs.

[How will this policy resolve the existing municipal electricity debt crisis?](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/#1787661103526-460702f0-0962)

The position paper acknowledges that many municipal distributors are not financially
viable and cannot meet the strict prudential (creditworthiness) requirements needed
to trade on the centralised wholesale platform. The state proposes creating intermediate
mechanisms allowing non-qualifying municipalities to procure power while separating
their retail sales business from network maintenance accounts. However, critics 
argue that without resolving the historical municipal debt owed to Eskom, introducing
an open wholesale market risks creating a two-tiered system where well-managed cities
thrive while debt-distressed municipalities face worsening service failures.

The  Position Paper

 ⌊Loader⌉ Loading...

 ⌊EAD Logo⌉ Taking too long?

 ⌊Reload⌉ Reload document

 | [ ⌊Open⌉ Open in new tab ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/25143304/260821Electricity_Sector_Market_Transformation_Position_Paper_removed.pdf)

[Download [1.33 MB] ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/25143304/260821Electricity_Sector_Market_Transformation_Position_Paper_removed.pdf)

The Government Notice

 ⌊Loader⌉ Loading...

 ⌊EAD Logo⌉ Taking too long?

 ⌊Reload⌉ Reload document

 | [ ⌊Open⌉ Open in new tab ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/25143346/260821Electricity_Sector_Market_Transformation_Position_Paper-notice.pdf)

[Download [49.20 KB] ](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/25143346/260821Electricity_Sector_Market_Transformation_Position_Paper-notice.pdf)

### _In the News_

    - BusinessTech — [End of a 103-year monopoly in South Africa](https://businesstech.co.za/news/energy/871593/end-of-a-103-year-monopoly-in-south-africa/)
    - Energize — [Power market participants face imbalance costs under reform plan](https://www.energize.co.za/article/power-market-participants-face-imbalance-costs-under-reform-plan)
    - Engineering News — [Cabinet approves release of revised electricity pricing policy and market transformation paper for comment](https://www.engineeringnews.co.za/article/cabinet-approves-release-of-revised-electricity-pricing-policy-and-market-transformation-paper-for-comment-2026-07-30)
    - TechCentral — [You still can’t choose who sells you electricity in South Africa](https://techcentral.co.za/you-still-cant-choose-who-sells-you-electricity-in-south-africa/285220/)
    - MyBroadband — [Proposed new electricity rules in South Africa will include penalties for technical mistakes](https://mybroadband.co.za/news/energy/663877-proposed-new-electricity-rules-in-south-africa-will-include-penalties-for-technical-mistakes.html)
    - Gov.za — [The just energy transition is gathering pace and creating opportunity](https://www.gov.za/blog/just-energy-transition-gathering-pace-and-creating-opportunity)
    - African Insider — [Why South Africa is dismantling Eskom’s 103-year electricity monopoly](https://www.africaninsider.com/business/why-south-africa-is-dismantling-eskoms-103-year-electricity-monopoly/)

### _Statements and media releases_

Click on a logo to view.

Want to display your organisation’s statement? [Click here. ](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary/ electricity@dearsouthafrica.co.za?subject=org info for Electricity discussion paper info page)

Close

### Cape Independence Party

 **CAPEXIT Party strongly opposes the Business Licensing Bill in its entirety on
all points:**

**Preferential licensing**
 The Bill explicitly empowers the Minister to grant licences
on a “preferential” basis and to impose conditions that advance “historically disadvantaged
individuals” or other designated groups. This is nothing less than state-sanctioned
racial and ideological discrimination dressed up as transformation policy.

CAPEXIT rejects the notion that the state has any legitimate role in deciding which
racial or social group may or may not operate a business. Such preferential licensing
will:

    - Reintroduce apartheid-era economic controls under a new ideological banner;
    - Create a cronyist system where access to markets is determined by political
      connections and demographic criteria rather than merit, innovation or consumer
      demand;
    - Discourage both domestic and foreign investment, as investors will rightly
      fear that their businesses can be denied licences or subjected to arbitrary
      conditions on racial or political grounds.

No free society licenses businesses on the basis of the owner’s skin colour or historical
narrative. This clause alone renders the entire Bill unconstitutional and morally
indefensible.

**Principles of business licensing**
 The Bill fails to articulate any coherent,
objective, or proportionate principle for requiring a general business licence in
the first place. Instead, it presumes that every enterprise – from a street vendor
to a multinational corporation – must seek prior permission from the state simply
to exist and trade.

This reverses the fundamental principle of a free economy: citizens should be free
to engage in lawful economic activity without state permission unless there is a
clear, evidence-based justification (e.g. public health, safety or environmental
protection).

The Bill provides no such justification. It is a blanket assault on economic freedom,
reminiscent of the licence-permit raj that crippled India’s economy for decades.
Requiring a general “business licence” in addition to existing sector-specific permits(
liquor, health, zoning, etc.) serves no legitimate public purpose – only the purpose
of expanding state control and creating new opportunities for rent-seeking and corruption.

**Powers of inspectors**
 The Bill grants inspectors extraordinarily broad and invasive
powers, including warrantless entry into private premises, seizure of documents 
and goods, and the ability to close businesses on the spot. These powers are ripe
for abuse and will be weaponised against political opponents, non-compliant businesses,
and any entrepreneur who refuses to pay bribes.

In a country already plagued by corruption scandals, handing unelected officials
the power to enter and shut down businesses without judicial oversight is an open
invitation to extortion. Small businesses, spaza shops, and informal traders – many
of them immigrant-owned – will be particularly vulnerable to harassment and shakedowns.
Far from promoting transformation, this will simply create a new class of “licence
inspectors” who enrich themselves at the expense of the poor.

**More red tape**
 South Africa already ranks poorly on the World Bank’s Ease of
Doing Business index, largely because of regulatory overreach. This Bill adds yet
another layer of costly, time-consuming bureaucracy on top of SARS registration,
municipal permits, B-BBEE compliance, UIF, COIDA, sector SETA requirements, and 
dozens of other licences.

The compliance costs – application fees, mandatory consultations, endless paperwork,
and the risk of arbitrary refusal – will crush startups and force thousands of small
businesses to close or remain informal. Jobs will be lost, investment will flee,
and the tax base will shrink. The Western Cape, which has consistently outperformed
the rest of South Africa precisely because of lighter and more efficient regulation,
will see its competitive advantage deliberately sabotaged by Pretoria.

**Conclusion**
 The Business Licensing Bill is not reform – it is economic sabotage.
It centralises power in the hands of an already overreaching and underperforming
national government, reintroduces racial criteria into commerce, and erects new 
barriers to entrepreneurship at a time when South Africa desperately needs growth
and jobs.

CAPEXIT calls for the complete withdrawal of this Bill. The people of the Western
Cape, and indeed all South Africans who believe in freedom, will not accept a return
to a permit-based economy controlled by bureaucrats and political gatekeepers.

For a free, prosperous, and non-racial future, this Bill must be rejected in its
entirety.
