# Electricity Transformation paper

- Link: https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/
- Published: 2026-08-25T14:09:35+02:00
- Author: dearSA

![The Department of Electricity and Energy has published a structural roadmap to
dismantle South Africa's single-buyer electricity model and replace it with a competitive
open market](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/25133849/
Electricity-sector-transformation-paper-HEADER-scaled.jpg "Electricity sector transformation
paper HEADER")

![DEAR-SOUTH-AfFRICA](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2023/
02/08135845/DEAR-SOUTH-AfFRICA.png "DEAR-SOUTH-AfFRICA")

0

comments individually delivered to the Minister, so far

### The Department of Electricity and Energy published a structural roadmap to dismantle South Africa’s single-buyer electricity model and replace it with a competitive open market: the South African Wholesale Electricity Market (SAWEM).

While market competition aims to end Eskom’s generation monopoly and encourage private
investment, the underlying policy introduces fundamental shifts that directly affect
your monthly utility bills and private solar investments:

    - _Mandatory Fixed Grid Charges on Rooftop Solar: _The policy explicitly targets
      grid-connected solar and partial-defection users under an “anti-free-riding”
      principle, shifting tariff structures from volumetric consumption (units used)
      to high, unavoidable fixed monthly connection fees.
    - _The “Captive Ratepayer” Risk:_ Large industrial and commercial users exceeding
      set thresholds (e.g., 1 MW) will be allowed to bypass municipal grids to buy
      cheaper power directly from private traders. Ordinary households and small
      businesses will remain “captive” to municipal distribution grids, risking 
      higher tariffs to cover municipal revenue deficits and legacy cross-subsidies.
    - _Wholesale Price Volatility & Market Power:_ With Eskom Generation remaining
      the dominant producer, risks of market power, pricing manipulation, and trading
      speculation could translate into retail tariff volatility if regulatory protections
      are inadequate.
    - _Restructuring the Distribution Value Chain:_ Municipal and Eskom distributors
      must separate the physical grid (“wires”) from electricity sales (“retail/
      trading”), introducing separate fees for grid delivery and energy units.

click the link for more info

[ view all comments and a report on the participation ](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary)

### Where Do You Stand?

🟢_ Support:_ Market competition, Eskom unbundling, and open wholesale trading are
essential to solve South Africa’s energy crisis and attract private capital.

🔴 _Object:_ Mandatory fixed solar charges, captive consumer price hikes, and municipal
revenue losses will hurt ordinary households and small businesses.

🟡 _Support with Amendments:_ Wholesale market reform should proceed only if strict
caps are placed on fixed network fees, captive ratepayers are protected, and municipal
cross-subsidies are safeguarded.

## Have your say – shape the paper. [CLOSED]

**Do you support the proposed Electricity Sector Market Transformation Position 
Paper? **

**What is your concern? (scroll down for an explanation of each) **

As you've chosen "all of the above", if you had to choose one concern, what would
it be?

**I am participating as a: **

the fields below are optional ——————————

**What is your preferred channel for feedback on this campaign?**

**Your preferred language?**

**What is your status? (for our reporting purposes only) **

 **Check your email address then hit send! You will be redirected to a confirmation
page. **

![D-icon](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/11192438/
D-icon-40x40-1.png "D-icon-40x40")

### _Top concerns_

[1: Mandatory Fixed Network Charges on Solar & Low-Volume Users ("Anti-Free Riding")](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/#1770131112026-5a70eb21-10f15d6a-e1cd1d69-9490bed6-ef95)

_What the Policy Proposes:_
 The position paper establishes the principle to “discourage
free riding,” arguing that modern electricity networks have high fixed infrastructure
costs and low operational costs. Under this framework, tariffs will shift away from
pure volumetric consumption charges (cents per kilowatt-hour) toward **mandatory
fixed capacity and network charges** for all grid-connected customers, regardless
of how little electricity they consume. Only consumers who disconnect completely
from the national grid will be exempt from these fixed fees.

_The Underlying Risk: _
 Households and small businesses that invested significant
private capital into rooftop solar, batteries, and energy efficiency to protect 
themselves from load shedding will be forced to pay higher monthly baseline connection
fees. This structural shift acts as a financial penalty on private decarbonisation,
extending solar payback periods and increasing electricity bills for low-volume 
and frugal users.

### Points to Demand in Your Public Submission:

    - Demand that NERSA place strict statutory caps on fixed network and capacity
      charges to prevent utilities from penalising private renewable investments.
    - Insist on a tiered tariff model that credits grid-tied rooftop solar owners
      for daytime energy injection, offsetting fixed network costs rather than imposing
      flat availability taxes.
    - Require an independent socio-economic impact assessment on how fixed monthly
      fees affect low-income and energy-conserving households.

[2: Captive Consumer Protections & Two-Tiered Tariff Risks](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/#1770131112043-0e75ef86-4b6c5d6a-e1cd1d69-9490bed6-ef95)

_What the Policy Proposes: _
 The policy introduces a dual market structure dividing
consumers into “Eligible Customers” and “Captive Customers.” Only large commercial
and industrial consumers exceeding a specified demand threshold (e.g., 1 MW) will
initially have the legal right to purchase directly on the open wholesale market
or contract with private traders. All residential households and smaller commercial
entities will remain “captive” to incumbent municipal or Eskom distribution retail
tariffs.

_The Underlying Risk: _
 Allowing the largest, highest-paying electricity users 
to exit municipal supply creates a two-tiered energy economy. As high-volume users
migrate to competitive private contracts, the fixed costs of maintaining legacy 
municipal networks and state-owned infrastructure will be concentrated onto captive
residential households, driving up standard retail tariffs.

### Points to Demand in Your Public Submission:

    - Demand a binding, published transition roadmap that progressively lowers the
      eligibility threshold, ensuring retail market choice is expanded to ordinary
      households and SMMEs rather than remaining an exclusive corporate privilege.
    - Require NERSA to implement mandatory tariff-parity benchmarks ensuring captive
      customer tariffs do not exceed wholesale-plus-efficient-delivery benchmark
      prices.
    - Oppose any mechanism that uses captive household tariffs to recover stranded
      costs or uncompetitive legacy contract premiums.

[3: Wholesale Market Power & Price Manipulation Risks](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/#1770131281853-5866958a-b51c5d6a-e1cd1d69-9490bed6-ef95)

_What the Policy Proposes: _
 Eskom Generation will participate in the South African
Wholesale Electricity Market (SAWEM) as a legally separate commercial entity competing
against independent power producers (IPPs). To prevent the abuse of market power—
such as economic withholding (bidding at artificially inflated rates) or physical
withholding (restricting supply to force price spikes)—the policy relies on transitional“
vesting contracts,” NERSA bid oversight, and a Market Surveillance Unit (MSU).

_The Underlying Risk: _
 Because Eskom Generation continues to control the vast 
majority of national baseload generating capacity, market surveillance alone may
be inadequate to prevent pricing distortions. In unbundled spot markets worldwide,
dominant generators and speculative trading desks have exploited dispatch rules 
to artificially inflate clearing prices, costs that are ultimately passed down to
retail consumers.

### Points to Demand in Your Public Submission:

    - Demand mandatory cost-reflective bidding caps for any single generation entity
      that controls more than 20% of active dispatchable capacity in the market.
    - Require full public transparency and real-time reporting of day-ahead and 
      intra-day market bidding data to enable independent civil oversight.
    - Mandate severe, legally enforceable financial penalties and license cancellations
      for participants found guilty of collusive bidding, capacity withholding, 
      or market manipulation.

[4: Municipal Financial Collapse & Loss of Cross-Subsidies](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/#1770131323251-266a4851-6c9c5d6a-e1cd1d69-9490bed6-ef95)

_What the Policy Proposes: _
 The position paper mandates the unbundling of electricity
distribution businesses into separate regulated network service providers (“wires”)
and licensed retail trading businesses. It also enforces strict prudential (creditworthiness)
requirements for wholesale market participation, while acknowledging that many municipal
distributors currently fail to meet baseline financial viability criteria.

_The Underlying Risk: _
 Local municipalities rely heavily on the profit margins
generated from bulk electricity sales to industrial and commercial clients to cross-
subsidise indigent households, free basic electricity (FBE), and municipal service
delivery. If large customers bypass local councils to purchase from private traders,
municipal distribution revenues could collapse, accelerating local government insolvency
and worsening service delivery failures across towns and cities.

### Points to Demand in Your Public Submission:

    - Demand that the Department of Electricity and Energy, National Treasury, and
      SALGA establish a ring-fenced National Municipal Transition Mechanism before
      large commercial users are permitted to bypass municipal distribution accounts.
    - Require municipal electricity distribution entities to ring-fence network 
      maintenance budgets into dedicated accounts to prevent tariff revenue from
      being diverted into general municipal administrative expenses.
    - Demand a transparent resolution framework for historical municipal bulk electricity
      debt that does not penalise paying ratepayers through inflated local tariffs.

[5: NTCSA Structural Conflicts of Interest & Independence](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/#1777463528421-99209505-be9a1d69-9490bed6-ef95)

_What the Policy Proposes: _
 The National Transmission Company of South Africa (
NTCSA) is designated to fulfill four critical, overlapping roles: Transmission Network
Service Provider (TNSP), System Operator (SO), Market Operator (MO), and Central
Purchasing Agency (CPA). While the Electricity Regulation Amendment Act provides
for its transition into a fully independent entity within five years, the NTCSA 
will initially remain a subsidiary under Eskom Holdings.

_The Underlying Risk: _
 Housing the market administrator (MO), grid controller (
SO), wires builder (TNSP), and legacy contract holder (CPA) within a single corporate
entity owned by Eskom Holdings creates severe structural conflicts of interest. 
The NTCSA could face internal pressure to prioritise Eskom Generation’s dispatch,
protect legacy IPP off-take agreements, or delay third-party grid connections at
the expense of private competitors and consumer choice.

### Points to Demand in Your Public Submission:

    - Demand that the five-year transition period for the full legal and operational
      independence of the NTCSA from Eskom Holdings be significantly shortened.
    - Mandate strict statutory ring-fencing, independent board governance, and separate
      accounting between the Market Operator (MO) and the Central Purchasing Agency(
      CPA).
    - Require an independent, external ombud mechanism to adjudicate grid access
      disputes, connection queue allocations, and dispatch fairness without regulatory
      delay.

[6: Transmission Congestion, Bottlenecks & Private Grid Expansion (ITPs)](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/#1777463564023-1723eae7-45f61d69-9490bed6-ef95)

_What the Policy Proposes: _
 The paper recognises that transmission network congestion
is a severe barrier to new generation capacity and proposes enabling private sector
investment through Independent Transmission Projects (ITPs) alongside NTCSA infrastructure
expansion. Grid congestion will be managed in the short term using “re-dispatching”
strategies and constraint pricing mechanisms.

_The Underlying Risk: _
 Grid capacity in the resource-rich Northern, Eastern, and
Western Cape is already fully committed, preventing gigawatts of cheaper private
renewable energy from coming online. Without a clear, bankable, and expedited regulatory
framework for private transmission investment (ITPs), transmission bottlenecks will
persist for years, causing market congestion costs and higher balancing fees to 
be passed onto end-users.

### Points to Demand in Your Public Submission:

    - Demand the immediate publication of a clear, standardized licensing and remuneration
      framework for Independent Transmission Projects (ITPs) to crowd in private
      capital for grid expansion.
    - Require transparent, non-discriminatory grid allocation rules that prevent
      transmission capacity hoarding by non-performing projects.
    - Insist that re-dispatching and congestion management costs caused by network
      delays be borne by network service providers rather than passed on to retail
      consumers through balancing surcharges.

### _Perspectives: What is the debate?_

The proposed Electricity Sector Market Transformation Position Paper represents 
the most consequential restructuring of South Africa’s energy landscape in decades.
At its core, the policy navigates a fundamental conflict: introducing free-market
competition and cost-reflective tariffs versus protecting municipal financial viability,
rooftop solar investments, and vulnerable captive consumers.

[What SUPPORTERS Say (The Case for Market Reform & Wholesale Competition)](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/#1770892117175-dfc38055-c8385d6a-e1cd1d69-9490bed6-ef95)

    - _Ending Monopolies and Unlocking Private Investment: _
       Decades of Eskom’s
      single-buyer monopoly led to catastrophic load shedding, debt bailouts, and
      stifled innovation. Establishing the South African Wholesale Electricity Market(
      SAWEM) allows private generators, renewable energy developers, and traders
      to compete directly, deploying private capital to build generation capacity
      without burdening national taxpayers.
    - _Transparent Price Discovery and Long-Term Cost Reductions: _
       Open day-ahead
      and intra-day wholesale trading forces generators to bid at competitive, marginal
      costs. Over time, this market mechanism removes operational inefficiencies,
      penalises unreliable power stations, and drives down the baseline wholesale
      cost of electricity for the entire economy.
    - _Fair System Cost Allocation (“Anti-Free Riding”): _
       The physical grid requires
      billions of Rands in fixed maintenance costs regardless of how much energy
      is consumed. Supporters argue that grid-tied rooftop solar owners still rely
      on the national grid for nighttime power and system stability. Shifting toward
      mandatory fixed capacity charges ensures that network costs are fairly shared
      across all connected users, rather than being disproportionately subsidised
      by poorer households without solar systems.
    - _Level Playing Field via Network Unbundling: _
       Legally unbundling the National
      Transmission Company of South Africa (NTCSA) and forcing distribution companies
      to separate physical “wires” from electricity trading ensures non-discriminatory
      grid access for everyone. Independent power producers will finally compete
      on equal terms with Eskom Generation.
    - _Professionalising Municipal Electricity Accounts: _
       Forcing municipalities
      to separate their retail trading businesses from network maintenance creates
      transparent accounting, prevents councils from diverting grid maintenance 
      funds to cover unrelated administrative shortfalls, and establishes cost-reflective
      pricing models.

[What OPPONENTS & SKEPTICS Say (The Case for Ratepayer & Solar Protection)](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/#1770892117205-3c7c32e1-ce3d5d6a-e1cd1d69-9490bed6-ef95)

    - _A “Sun Tax” on Private Capital and Rooftop Solar: _
       Millions of households
      and businesses invested private savings into rooftop solar and batteries to
      keep their lights on when the state failed to do so. Replacing consumption-
      based billing with mandatory, high fixed monthly network charges penalises
      energy-conscious citizens, extends solar payback periods, and discourages 
      private decarbonisation.
    - _The “Captive Ratepayer Trap” and Municipal Insolvency: _
       Large industrial
      and commercial users exceeding demand thresholds (e.g., 1 MW) will be allowed
      to exit municipal supply to buy cheaper wholesale or private power. This strips
      municipalities of high-margin corporate revenue used to cross-subsidise indigent
      households and basic services, leaving captive residential ratepayers to shoulder
      skyrocketing local tariffs and degraded grid maintenance.
    - _Wholesale Price Volatility and Market Power Manipulation: _
       Eskom Generation
      still controls the overwhelming majority of South Africa’s dispatchable baseload
      power. In unbundled spot markets worldwide, dominant suppliers have engaged
      in economic or physical withholding to artificially spike market clearing 
      prices. Without hard statutory bid caps and aggressive oversight, wholesale
      price volatility will be passed directly down to retail consumers.
    - _Severe Conflicts of Interest Within the NTCSA: _
       Consolidating transmission
      grid ownership (TNSP), system dispatch (SO), market clearing (MO), and legacy
      state off-take contracts (CPA) within a single entity under Eskom Holdings
      creates structural conflicts of interest. NTCSA could face internal commercial
      pressure to favour Eskom assets or delay third-party grid connections.
    - _Premature Market Launch Amid Unresolved Municipal Debt: _
       Opening an advanced
      wholesale market with mandatory imbalance penalties in 2026/2027 while municipal
      distribution debt to Eskom remains unresolved is premature. Financially distressed
      municipalities that fail prudential credit requirements will be excluded from
      trading platforms, creating a divided nation of well-supplied metros and failing,
      power-starved rural councils.

[ View more info](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/electricity-transformation-paper/summary)
