# Dear Mr President

- Link: https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/dear-mr-president/
- Published: 2023-12-06T16:39:39+02:00
- Author: dearSA

_Advert_

_Advert – scroll down_

![Have your say to stop Ramaphosa signing the Hate Speech Bill into law](https://
cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/06161948/Dear-mr-President-
Hate-Speech-copy.jpg "Dear mr President - Hate Speech copy")

![ForSA-DSA](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/19155518/
ForSA-DSA.png "ForSA-DSA")

### **7238 **comments delivered to the Presidency

click the link for more info, or scroll down to have your say

[click to view info, statements, documents and videos ](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/dear-mr-president/summary)

[click to view comments from other participants ](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/dear-mr-president/comments)

### The National Assembly (NA) has passed the highly contested Prevention and Combating of **Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill** now just needing President Cyril Ramaphosa’s signature.

**CONSTITUTIONAL CONCERNS ABOUT THE BILL’S DEFINITION OF “HATE SPEECH”: **

The Bill contravenes section 36 of the Constitution, because it is:

    1. **Unnecessary** as existing laws have already been successfully implemented 
       in various criminal and civil cases of hate speech.
    2. **Overbroad**: The Bill’s definition of “hate speech” is broader than the Constitution’s
       definition of hate speech, criminalising speech the Constitution sees as protected.
       
       The Bill’s definition of “hate speech” is also broader than the Equality Act’s
       civil law definition of (civil) hate speech. This will make it easier to be 
       found guilty of a criminal offence and sent to jail for up to five years than
       to be ordered to e.g. apologise under the Equality Act.
    3. **Vague and ambiguous:** The Bill’s different elements for the crime of hate
       speech are either undefined (e.g. hate) or vague and/or ambiguous (e.g. social
       cohesion).

The Bill also contravenes the Constitution’s founding value of the rule of the law(
section 1(c)), because **it fails to define the essential element of “hate”.** The
result is that citizens are unable to know beforehand whether they are committing
a crime or not.

## Have your say right away.

**Do you want President Ramaphosa to sign the Hate Speech Bill into law as is? **

**What is your top concern? (scroll down to view full details) **

**Do you want to use the "Dear Mr President" template? (scroll down to view) **

**What is your preferred channel for feedback on this campaign?**

**Your preferred language?**

**What is your status? (for our reporting purposes only) **

**Check your email address then hit send! You will be redirected to a confirmation
page. **

![D-icon](https://cdn.dearsouthafrica.co.za/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/11192438/
D-icon-40x40-1.png "D-icon-40x40")

An important message from Michael Swain – On 5 December 2023 Parliament passed the
Hate Speech Bill – a law which will directly impact our right to freedom of religion!
The Bill will now go to the President to be signed into law. Once President Ramaphosa
signs it, it will be enforceable.

**TAKE ACTION!
 
Write to President Ramaphosa to appeal to him not to sign the Bill
into law! The Constitution (section 79(1)) allows him to send the Bill back to Parliament
if he has concerns about whether it is constitutional or not!

### Dear Mr President (Template)

The Prevention and Combating of Hate Crimes and Hate Speech Bill (the Bill), passed
by the National Assembly on Tuesday, 5 December 2023, refers.

**REQUEST**:

I am writing to appeal to Your Excellency to send the Bill back to the National 
Assembly for reconsideration, because of the constitutional concerns below.

**CONSTITUTIONAL CONCERNS ABOUT THE BILL’S DEFINITION OF “HATE SPEECH”:**

The Bill contravenes section 36 of the Constitution, because it is:

 1.  a. **Unnecessary** as existing laws have already been successfully implemented in
        various criminal and civil cases of hate speech.
     b. **Overbroad**: The Bill’s definition of “hate speech” is broader than the Constitution’s
        definition of hate speech, criminalising speech the Constitution sees as protected.
        
        The Bill’s definition of “hate speech” is also broader than the Equality Act’s
        civil law definition of (civil) hate speech. This will make it easier to be found
        guilty of a criminal offence and sent to jail for up to five years than to be 
        ordered to e.g. apologise under the Equality Act.
     c. **Vague and ambiguous:** The Bill’s different elements for the crime of hate speech
        are either undefined (e.g. hate) or vague and/or ambiguous (e.g. social cohesion).

The Bill also contravenes the Constitution’s founding value of the rule of the law(
section 1(c)), because it fails to define the essential element of “hate”. The result
is that citizens are unable to know beforehand whether they are committing a crime
or not.

**OTHER CONCERNS ABOUT THE BILL:**

The Bill fails to incorporate the United Nations’ Rabat Plan of Action threshold
test (the requirements used to determine culpability for criminal hate speech). 
Thus it will cause South Africa to break its international law obligations and commitments
to: uphold freedom of expression and impose criminal sanctions for hate speech only
as a last resort measure in strictly justifiable circumstances.

[View more info ](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/dear-mr-president/summary/)
