# comments3

- Link: https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/crypto-assets-manual/comments3/
- Published: 2026-09-16T14:08:34+02:00
- Author: dearSA

_Advert_

_Advert – scroll down_

Displaying the **30** latest comments.

[ have your say](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/crypto-assets-manual/)

  |

Submitted

 |

first-name

 |

support

 |

concern

 |

top-concern

 |

message

 |  
   |

2026-11-13 17:11:03 +02:00

 |

Mfuphi

 |

Not fully

 |

All of the above

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

If the effort is to prevent money laundering, I think more creative ways ought to be explored. This punishes those who already hold digital assets. Furthermore, it limits the country from moving with a forever changing technological environment. The world is ever evolving technologically, so we have to find regulatory ways that evolve with technology as opposed to discouraging citizens from participating in ever evolving economical activities.

 | 
 |

2026-11-13 11:52:08 +02:00

 |

Abram Philip

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

I do not support the draft Crypto Asset Manual as published. Banning inward transfers from self-custody wallets, and banning businesses from making cross-border payments in crypto, goes far beyond what anti-money-laundering controls need. It also treats crypto differently from other technology. A R5 million locked-capital requirement will push smaller local service providers out of the market. Issuing the manual before the parent Capital Flow Management Regulations are final creates uncertainty, so I ask SARB to revise it once those regulations are settled.

 | 
 |

2026-11-12 09:53:31 +02:00

 |

Martin

 |

No I do not

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-11-12 08:13:17 +02:00

 |

Corli

 |

No I do not

 |

Threat to Domestic Fintech Jobs, Foreign Investment & Tax Revenue

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-11-11 14:10:36 +02:00

 |

virgil

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

Discrimination Against Technology (Breach of Governor Kganyago's Principle)

 |

 | 
 |

2026-11-10 13:26:33 +02:00

 |

Leoni

 |

Not fully

 |

All of the above

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

I support lawful tax declarations and measures against fraud and money laundering, but oppose unnecessary state interference in privately owned crypto assets. Moving assets to my own wallet should not automatically be treated as an offshore transfer. Individuals should be free to hold crypto assets and use them for lawful payments where both parties agree, with proportionate reporting requirements that respect financial privacy.

 | 
 |

2026-11-10 06:02:57 +02:00

 |

Linnea

 |

No I do not

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

 |

Banning inward self-custody transfers forces individuals to keep their funds on an exchange. The whole point of crypocurrency is eliminating the need for trusting large third party institutions to safeguard your wealth.

 | 
 |

2026-11-09 23:43:37 +02:00

 |

Esaiah

 |

No I do not

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-11-02 10:27:35 +02:00

 |

Trevor and Christel

 |

Not fully

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

 |

Even for those who do not use any Crypto, just the thought that Government and SARS actions 'suggest' getting to allow or disallow any citizen access to their own property is a great warning sign. It can 'open' the door for them to find another 'loophole' towards control of citizens private income/capital of any sort. The only thing Government and SARS should have 'privy' too is to make sure money doesn't 'leak' out of the country under 'misguided' (Really illegal) transactions.

 | 
 |

2026-11-01 09:11:50 +02:00

 |

Leon

 |

No I do not

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-29 07:06:24 +02:00

 |

Noel

 |

No I do not

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-28 11:52:19 +02:00

 |

Jacobus

 |

No I do not

 |

Other

 |

 |

Despots and tyrants need to regulate, ban and block that which can free the people from their tyranny.

 | 
 |

2026-10-28 11:32:17 +02:00

 |

Makhosazana

 |

No I do not

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

 |

Individuala are legally prohibited from ever returning those assets to a licensed domestic exchange to liquidate into Rand. Inward transfers are only permitted if sent directly from an offshore Authorised CASP. This treats personal self-custody as illegitimate and traps savings offshore or outside the domestic banking network.

 | 
 |

2026-10-26 08:11:58 +02:00

 |

kate

 |

No I do not

 |

Other

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-23 15:03:46 +02:00

 |

Abrie

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-22 21:24:34 +02:00

 |

Jaime

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

While the aims of modernising exchange controls, aligning with FATF standards and combating illicit flows are legitimate, the draft achieves the opposite of sound, technology-neutral regulation.
It creates a “cold storage trap” by treating transfers from self-hosted wallets into local authorised platforms as non-permissible. Individuals may move crypto out under the existing allowances, but are then blocked from returning it to a licensed South African exchange to sell into rand. This penalises ordinary self-custody rather than illicit activity.It also imposes a blanket prohibition on South African companies using crypto for any cross-border transaction. The same commercial payment that is permitted via traditional banking rails is banned when settled through a regulated blockchain channel. This directly contradicts the principle of technology neutrality previously stated by the SARB Governor and places local businesses at a structural disadvantage.These measures will push activity into less transparent channels, raise costs for legitimate users, and undermine the competitiveness of South Africa’s fintech sector. The manual should be substantially revised to permit inward transfers from self-custody subject to ordinary customer due diligence, and to give resident entities equivalent cross-border treatment to that available through banks.

 | 
 |

2026-10-21 08:36:43 +02:00

 |

Rixie

 |

No I do not

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

 |

Inward transfers should be permitted subject to standard Customer Due Diligence (CDD), source-of-funds verification, and blockchain forensic risk scoring under the FIC Act.

 | 
 |

2026-10-20 09:57:00 +02:00

 |

Michele

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-20 09:00:24 +02:00

 |

Mighael Hans

 |

Yes I do

 |

The Blanket Prohibition on Corporate/Business Cross-Border Payments

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-20 07:51:36 +02:00

 |

Rui

 |

No I do not

 |

Discrimination Against Technology (Breach of Governor Kganyago's Principle)

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-17 12:17:45 +02:00

 |

Paul

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-16 21:18:32 +02:00

 |

Colin

 |

No I do not

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-16 16:38:37 +02:00

 |

ETIENNE

 |

No I do not

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-16 16:32:55 +02:00

 |

Gavin

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

I demand that FinSurv remove the non-permissible classification for inward transfers from self-hosted wallets. Inward transfers should be permitted subject to standard Customer Due Diligence (CDD), source-of-funds verification, and blockchain forensic risk scoring under the FIC Act.

 | 
 |

2026-10-16 11:15:05 +02:00

 |

Kyle

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

I believe this is dressed up under false pretenses. The SARB is a private centralized institution that wants control of all South Africans and their funds. Decentralized systems, through their transparent and sovereign means, will reveal the way they fraudulently control the financial system and attempt to maintain the highest level of control in our country, continuing to benefit shareholders or central banks, the International Bank of Settlements, International Monetary Fund, and the World Bank, among others. 
This is an outrageous attempt to violate the basic human rights of property ownership and the right to prosper.

 | 
 |

2026-10-16 09:28:00 +02:00

 |

Johan

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-15 13:06:47 +02:00

 |

Louisa

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

The government taxes you in the money earned and can see when monies are deposited into your bank account therefore you are already tax and the flow of money is already captured and recorded, so why would the government want to restrict the method of money movement.

 | 
 |

2026-10-13 19:02:20 +02:00

 |

mark

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

The Inward Self-Custody Trap (Banning transfers from non-custodial wallets)

 |

some of the points will give goverment more power that will be used to abuse us in other areas also

 | 
 |

2026-10-13 07:16:59 +02:00

 |

Tracy

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

Threat to Domestic Fintech Jobs, Foreign Investment & Tax Revenue

 |

 | 
 |

2026-10-12 22:01:01 +02:00

 |

Sipho

 |

No I do not

 |

Privacy Overreach & Permanent Ledger Tracking (POPIA / Section 14)

 |

 |

I am concerned about the privacy implications and overreach of the Crypto Asset Manual. The permanent ledger tracking requirements violate privacy rights and create unnecessary surveillance burdens on ordinary South Africans.

 |

[What Supporters Say (National Treasury & SARB Stance)](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/crypto-assets-manual/comments3/#1770892117175-dfc38055-c8382881-c4081814-898b)

    - _Curbing Regulatory Arbitrage: _
       Unregulated cross-border crypto movements
      undermine the foreign exchange framework. Bringing crypto transactions within
      standard balance-of-payments reporting ensures that fintech entities face 
      the same compliance oversight as commercial banks.
    - _Defending the Fiscus & National Currency: _
       In an era of borderless digital
      finance, untracked capital outflows threaten domestic macroeconomic stability
      and the South African Rand. Comprehensive surveillance enables FinSurv to 
      track the true volume of capital moving across borders.
    - _Protecting International Financial Standing: _
       Following South Africa’s 
      removal from the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) grey list, closing cross-
      border anti-money laundering and counter-terrorist financing (AML/CFT) loopholes
      is necessary to maintain global banking relationships.
    - _Ensuring Platform Solvency: _
       Enforcing a minimum unimpaired capital reserve
      of R5 million and mandating client asset segregation protects everyday consumers
      from exchange collapses and fraudulent practices.
    - _Structured Industry Pathways: _
       The manual replaces legal ambiguity with
      a defined, tiered licensing model (Category 1, 2, and 3), providing institutional
      legitimacy for compliant operators.

[What Opponents Say (Industry Coalition, Economists & Legal Scholars)](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/crypto-assets-manual/comments3/#1770892117205-3c7c32e1-ce3d2881-c4081814-898b)

    - _Breach of Technology Neutrality: _
       SARB Governor Lesetja Kganyago stated
      that “similar payment activities should be subject to similar regulatory expectations,
      whether they are performed by a bank or a fintech.” The draft manual breaches
      this principle by permitting businesses to execute international vendor settlements
      via SWIFT while outright banning the exact same economic transaction if routed
      through regulated blockchain rails.
    - _The “Cold Storage Trap”: _
       Classifying inward transfers from non-custodial
      wallets as non-permissible penalizes the foundational property of public blockchain
      technology: individual self-custody. It creates a one-way street where citizens
      can take custody of their digital property, but are legally locked out of 
      the domestic banking system if they ever wish to repatriate it.
    - _Economic Isolation of South African Enterprise: _
       Banning South African 
      companies and trusts from cross-border crypto rails isolates the domestic 
      tech sector, digital exporters, and Web3 startups from the global digital 
      economy, preventing them from using efficient stablecoin settlement channels.
    - _Threat to Domestic Jobs & Foreign Investment: _
       The industry-led CATASTROPHE
      coalition (including VALR, Luno, AltCoinTrader, and EasyEquities) warns that
      billions of Rands in foreign direct investment into South African fintech 
      have been frozen, putting thousands of skilled jobs and significant corporate
      and PAYE tax contributions at immediate risk.
    - _Perverse Incentive for Unregulated Flight: _
       Imposing non-workable restrictions
      will not stop digital asset usage; it will simply drive liquidity away from
      compliant domestic exchanges into unregulated offshore peer-to-peer (P2P) 
      networks, blinding both FinSurv and SARS.
    - _Administrative Cart Before the Horse: _
       Requesting public commentary on 
      operational directives while the parent Capital Flow Management Regulations
      remain unresolved undermines procedural fairness under PAJA.
