# comments

- Link: https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/cape-baboon-relocation/comments/
- Published: 2026-10-07T16:25:33+02:00
- Author: dearSA

_Advert_

_Advert – scroll down_

Displaying the **5** latest comments.

[ view more ...](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/cape-baboon-relocation/comments2/)

  |

Submitted

 |

first-name

 |

support

 |

concern

 |

top-concern

 |

message

 |  
   |

2026-11-17 11:50:59 +02:00

 |

Ella

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

6. Failure to Formally Assess Funded Free-Ranging Coexistence Alternatives

 |

 | 
 |

2026-11-17 11:50:54 +02:00

 |

Lynne

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

3. Extreme Spatial Compression: 292x Territory Reduction and Welfare Harm

 |

 | 
 |

2026-11-17 11:50:24 +02:00

 |

Gabriela

 |

No I do not

 |

Other

 |

 |

These animals should not be caged, period.

 | 
 |

2026-11-17 11:50:13 +02:00

 |

Deborah

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

6. Failure to Formally Assess Funded Free-Ranging Coexistence Alternatives

 |

 | 
 |

2026-11-17 11:49:35 +02:00

 |

Jessica

 |

No I do not

 |

All of the above

 |

3. Extreme Spatial Compression: 292x Territory Reduction and Welfare Harm

 |

 |

[What Authorities and Proponents Say](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/cape-baboon-relocation/comments/#1770892117175-dfc38055-c8382881-c40848a0-9444)

    - _Mitigating Severe Human-Wildlife Conflict: _
       The Joint Task Team maintains
      that the Waterfall and Seaforth troops have become chronically urbanised in
      Simon’s Town, creating substantial human-wildlife conflict, property damage,
      and safety risks that previous management methods have failed to resolve.
    - _Non-Lethal Management Solution: _
       Authorities argue that permanent confinement
      in a purpose-built “semi-wild” Urban Wildlife Centre is preferable to euthanasia
      or leaving troops in urban environments where they face dog attacks, vehicle
      collisions, illegal pellet-gun shootings, and poisoning.
    - _Protecting Regional Genetic Lines: _
       Proponents state that purpose-built
      enclosures provide shelter, water, and veterinary care while preventing troops
      from raiding residential waste and human food attractants.
    - _Established Strategy: _
       The JTT asserts that baboon management has been 
      continuously informed by extensive consultation, including the 2023 Strategic
      Management Plan public-participation process and review by an independent 
      expert panel.

[What Conservationists, Experts, and Opponents Say](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/cape-baboon-relocation/comments/#1770892117205-3c7c32e1-ce3d2881-c40848a0-9444)

    - _Regulatory Prematurity & Missing Permits: _
       CapeNature confirmed on 29 September
      2026 that a completed captivity permit application has not been submitted 
      and the operational management plan remains unfinalised. Capturing, transporting,
      and caging protected wildlife without completed statutory permits violates
      the Nature Conservation Ordinance 19 of 1974.
    - _Severe Spatial Confinement: _
       Spatial tracking by primatologist Dr David
      Gaynor shows the Waterfall troop’s natural territory spans 736.1 hectares.
      Caging them in a 2.52-hectare enclosure (with the JTT enclosure specified 
      at 2.3 hectares) reduces their living range by ~292 times, which experts warn
      constitutes a monument to management failure and an unviable welfare outcome.
    - _Procedural Unfairness under PAJA: _
       The authorities substituted the announced
      November 2025 Plateau Road staged trial (which included a 6-month review and
      EIAs) with permanent confinement at Kogelfontein without conducting a specific
      notice-and-comment process under Section 4 of PAJA.
    - Refusal to Mitigate Waste Attractants: The City rolled out 2,200 baboon-proof
      bins across the Peninsula in September 2026 but intentionally excluded Simon’s
      Town on the grounds that the troops are earmarked for removal. Opponents argue
      the City is manufacturing a justification for removal by refusing to secure
      municipal waste.
    - _Viable Coexistence Alternatives Ignored: _
       A fully costed, funded alternative
      developed by WAPFSA and Dr Gaynor—incorporating strategic exclusion fencing,
      waste securement, and shepherding—has been bypassed without formal, transparent
      comparative assessment.
    - _Animal Welfare Objections: _
       The Cape of Good Hope SPCA formally stated 
      in July 2026 that it opposes placing healthy, free-roaming, wild-caught baboons
      into long-term captive sanctuaries.

[ have your say](https://dearsouthafrica.co.za/cape-baboon-relocation/#havasay)
